A place for more technical discussions. Please make sure you post in the correct section on the site, this way it keeps the site tidy AND ensures you get a more relevant answer.
Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
- Kellyhall87
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
-
Registered
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
09 Mar 2024 09:21 #254958
by Kellyhall87
Replied by Kellyhall87 on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
Thank you, that was the first mechanics first thought but fuel leak was ruled out there were no signs , as well as a choked catalytic converter, fuel filter. It happens when the engine is mid temp so not hot and not cold. It’s so strange. The first mechanic that came to rescue me spent 2 hours investigating all the possible problems that would come about from the symptoms and he said it was like they were all separate problems (which he checked) but it surely wouldn’t be possible for them all to happen at the exact same moment.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jackonlyjack
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Registered
Less
More
- Posts: 2966
- Thank you received: 667
09 Mar 2024 09:54 #254960
by jackonlyjack
Replied by jackonlyjack on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
when you say mid temp.....do you mean the needle is at midway on gauge
This is ideal temp for crank sensor to play up
I would look at getting a good second hand one to try
If you buy a new one don't buy a cheap one
This is ideal temp for crank sensor to play up
I would look at getting a good second hand one to try
If you buy a new one don't buy a cheap one
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Kellyhall87
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
-
Registered
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
09 Mar 2024 10:21 #254962
by Kellyhall87
Replied by Kellyhall87 on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
Yes, sorry I meant the needle is in the middle. Ok, I’ll look into a good second hand sensor and hope that will be it. Thank you so much.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jackonlyjack
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Registered
Less
More
- Posts: 2966
- Thank you received: 667
09 Mar 2024 10:46 #254963
by jackonlyjack
Replied by jackonlyjack on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
it's located behind the alternator
for now you could try spraying it with cold water like facade says
for now you could try spraying it with cold water like facade says
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
09 Mar 2024 19:00 #254977
by Hughes
Replied by Hughes on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
Are you 100% sure its not coils or plug wires? Make sure they are good ones if they have been replaced (you'll see why shortly).
I chased a misfire problem a couple years ago for weeks. Replaced coils, plugs, plug wires, still misfired badly under load. Started replacing sensors: cam, crank etc. with no luck. I took it to a mechanic around the corner from work and he could find nothing wrong either, even with his fancy scanner thingamy. checked over the fuel system, injectors etc all kinds of stuff. Eventually I gave up and took it into a reputable (but expensive) auto electrician/mechanic who specialises in diesel injection systems, asking him to check the fuel system for me properly. A few hours later he rang back and told me the brand new coils I put in a few weeks earlier were junk. They were a decent mid range aftermarket brand, (at least i thought so at the time) - VDO I believe the brand was.
The mechanic even rang the parts store I got them from (Repco, a common chain store in NZ, a division of NAPA) and told them to give me my money back.
They swapped in a set of genuine coils and fixed the issue immediately.
It was misfiring and jerking and popping when you'd accelerate under load, along with a rich fuel smell as unburned fuel exited the tailpipe.
May not be your issue, but in hindsight would cost me half as much to just get genuine parts the first time round.
I chased a misfire problem a couple years ago for weeks. Replaced coils, plugs, plug wires, still misfired badly under load. Started replacing sensors: cam, crank etc. with no luck. I took it to a mechanic around the corner from work and he could find nothing wrong either, even with his fancy scanner thingamy. checked over the fuel system, injectors etc all kinds of stuff. Eventually I gave up and took it into a reputable (but expensive) auto electrician/mechanic who specialises in diesel injection systems, asking him to check the fuel system for me properly. A few hours later he rang back and told me the brand new coils I put in a few weeks earlier were junk. They were a decent mid range aftermarket brand, (at least i thought so at the time) - VDO I believe the brand was.
The mechanic even rang the parts store I got them from (Repco, a common chain store in NZ, a division of NAPA) and told them to give me my money back.
They swapped in a set of genuine coils and fixed the issue immediately.
It was misfiring and jerking and popping when you'd accelerate under load, along with a rich fuel smell as unburned fuel exited the tailpipe.
May not be your issue, but in hindsight would cost me half as much to just get genuine parts the first time round.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Kellyhall87
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
-
Registered
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
12 Mar 2024 09:16 #255033
by Kellyhall87
Replied by Kellyhall87 on topic Help needed - 2011 Jimny violent knocking, shaking, engine cuts out and fuel
Hi Hughes, the first mechanic took the plugs out and checked them all and considered they were in good condition as well as the coils. After checking there was no fuel leak, he checked for misfiring but to no avail. However, what I’ll do is when it goes back in the garage I’ll mention both suggestions I’ve got from here so far just to be extra sure!
Interestingly, I took it on a long trip at the weekend, and instead of using the E10 fuel, I used Vpower and added a shot of redex. It has been running really well. I wonder if I have two different issues that just happen to fail at the same time? Fuel management issues and the sensor?
Interestingly, I took it on a long trip at the weekend, and instead of using the E10 fuel, I used Vpower and added a shot of redex. It has been running really well. I wonder if I have two different issues that just happen to fail at the same time? Fuel management issues and the sensor?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.157 seconds